Contextual Theology: The Voice of the House Church Must Be Heard

Editor’s note: As the church in China grows, she not only gleans from the centuries of theology done before she arrived on the scene; she has something particular to add to the conversation. There are, of course, numerous obstacles to clearly hearing the house church’s voice; however, the particular struggles and insights of the Chinese church as she contextualizes the Christian story are of great value to the global church.

“Urban Farmer” is a pseudonym used by an American who works to support and strengthen the Chinese house church.

The Need for Homegrown Theology


Would You Pray With Us Today?

Sign up to receive our weekly prayer emails with requests for the house church in China

In the 1950s and 60s, social scientists around the world prognosticated the demise of religion in modern society, based on the Enlightenment idea that modernization will lead to the decline of religion. It seems those predictions were grossly exaggerated. Instead, the world is “as furiously religious as it ever was.”

One of the most obvious examples of this desecularization is the growth of the Christian church in Mainland China. Well-documented reports of church growth have been done over the past several decades. While there are vast differences in the estimates of the exact size of the Christian population in China, it is unlikely any reports would offer a counter-narrative to this growth—both within government-sanctioned churches, as well as unregistered house churches.

With this growth has come the need for trained church leaders and contextualized theology. Over the past two decades, articles surveying government churches have reported on the need to provide more theologically-trained clergy, as well as calling to improve existing theological education. Both government and house churches recognize the need for homegrown, contextualized theology that interacts with the global church community.

The State of Chinese Seminary Education

In the past, unregistered house church leaders have encountered numerous difficulties in engaging in formal theological education. The number of unregistered churches outstrips those sanctioned by the government, yet the demand for formal, highly structured theological training far exceeds the supply. As the house church has grown in both size and agency, they are less marginalized, and more able to provide necessary educational services for church members. Many house churches have begun to provide unregistered, non-government-sanctioned theological training. Matters related to China’s house church are very challenging to document, due to the sensitive nature of participating in studies. Articles addressing this area are relatively scarce. There is a great need to explore house church theological training and gather data to better understand this field.

How do house church seminary students make meaning of their education? One important element of theological education is its transformative potential. Romans 12:2 calls for transformation by “the renewing of our minds.” 2 Corinthians 3:18 expresses a change that takes place as we transform into the likeness of God’s glory. Both passages use the same Greek root for the word we translate as “transform.” Theological education should, in some way, reflect the transformation spoken of in these passages. In Romans 12, the transformation taking place in our “minds” connotes more than mere intellectual knowledge, but points to a deeper sense of “moral consciousness,” a transformation that takes place at a profoundly deep level. This transformation is ongoing and lasts throughout life. It can be classified as a learning exercise, the goal of which is to confirm and approve of God’s will. God’s will is a moral compass, the supreme norm that guides us through the work of the Holy Spirit.

2 Corinthians 3:18 speaks of transformation in terms of the imago dei in humanity. This image of God displayed in humanity was once broken by the fall (Genesis 3), but is now being restored in God’s redeemed through union with Jesus Christ for the glory of God. Once again,  transformation is a life-long process.

Contextualization: The Intersection of Theology and Culture

Nearly twenty years ago, some in the Chinese church claimed that talk of a moral or spiritual “vacuum” within Chinese culture was greatly mistaken. In more recent years, however, the consensus is that such a “spiritual vacuumdoes indeed exist. Whether or not this vacuum is the cause for Christian conversion is uncertain; nonetheless, it is highly relevant to ask why such a vacuum exists. There is no one, singular factor that serves as the cause, but rather a combination of factors. Since the turn of the 20th century, China has undergone massive upheaval. Today, China faces cultural conflict brought about by a desire to rapidly catch up with industrialization, while maintaining some of its traditional cultural values.

This is not just a phenomenon within China, but one other Asian nations have experienced, and a poignant backdrop for the contextualization of theology in Asia. Asia’s embrace of Western modernization and industrialization has brought both benefits and drawbacks, as countries once isolated are in closer contact with one another. With this come opportunities and challenges for the church.  

Cultural incongruity and the spiritual vacuum are just two dilemmas that present themselves to Mainland Chinese. These and other dilemmas contribute to a lingering tension that one must accept as part of daily life. Many leaders in the church in China have addressed these issues in their theologizing, but house and government churches often come to vastly different conclusions in how to apply the gospel to this context. Government churches—known formally as the Three-Self Patriotic Movement— combine elements of ecumenical theology and socialist ideology to keep in line with the political agenda of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP).

House churches, however, have another dilemma they must consider. The vast majority of unregistered house churches, both urban and rural, are not fully legal. Most operate in “gray” or “black” regions of being illegal or ambiguously illegal. Since 1949, the CCP’s religious policy has fluctuated between enlightenment atheism (which treats religion as backward but tolerable), and militant atheism (which sees religion as a dangerous opiate of the masses). For house churches, this creates a dilemma, an important factor in understanding their context and identity. Most unregistered churches have only two choices: cooperation or resistance. Those who resist follow in the legacy of men like Wang Mingdao, considered by many to be the primary representative of those in the house church tradition.  

To understand this resistance position we need to look at Wang and those who follow in his footsteps. Understanding Wang’s background, context and theology reveals the guiding principles of his approach. These principles were: 1) the authority of scripture, 2) a fundamental belief in the separation of church and state, 3) Christian piety, 4) a nuanced approach to popular culture and media, and 5) a rejection of holy and secular dualism concerning one’s job. Resistance is not seen as disengagement from culture, but rather a position that runs counter to socialist ideals as manifested in China. 

Who Dictates the Theological Conversation of the Global Church?

These dilemmas provide the background in which the church must make meaning of her existence. Cultural incongruity raises the question of interaction with the West. Many of the early Three-Self leaders were educated in the West. During the 1970s and 80s, many in the rural house church looked to Western evangelicalism and the charismatic renewal movement for help. In more recent years, many urban house churches have turned toward historical Reformed theology and Calvinism, borrowing doctrines and concepts to address their dilemmas. For government and house churches, looking abroad might mean different things, but  is still a common denominator in the way they approach dilemmas.

The subtle distinction revolves not around whether borrowing resources from Western theology is acceptable, but rather what kind. How much will the Chinese church allow Western influence to dictate the theological conversation? An even more subtle factor is the question of who is allowed to participate in the conversation. Power dynamics in China demand that the Three-Self movement and the government must be in control, limiting the conversation to ideas and doctrines deemed politically in-line with Communist ideology.  House churches have the potential to interact with a broader audience of theological voices.

The topic then turns to the definition of contextualization. “Borrowing” theological resources is inevitable in an increasingly globalized world, and not necessarily antithetical to contextualization. The word “contextualization” was coined in the 1970s by Shoki Coe, a leader in the Taiwanese church. This idea was presented as a way to reform theological education in younger churches, which were mission field churches during the colonial era. The goal was to emphasize self-theologizing through critical contextualizing and a deeper understanding of the gospel, thus driving the church away from being a mission church and toward being missional. Many evangelical churches were slow to adapt contextualization, citing the authority of scripture, but over time came to see its necessity.  

Some studies in contextual theology focus on those who politically resist oppression and the abuse of power. The problem with this focus is with how we define those terms. Distinctions become clouded when the political system that once stood for and still claims to stand for resisting oppression and power abuse then becomes the source of oppression for many within its borders, as is the case in China. Those who resist the political system of oppression then battle with their oppressors over who defines these terms. While resisting oppression is important, it is not adequate as a defining principle. Self-theologizing must take into consideration other factors.

At least one of the determining factors in contextualization should be who does the theologizing and where they do it. Theology that answers contextual questions is important—but who gets to pick which questions are important? Are they being answered within the contextual “soil” by those who grew up in that soil? Those inside the soil may choose to converse with different theological voices abroad based on the needs that face them. This is at least part of what Coe was trying to promote: greater agency and contribution to the global conversation. Are inside voices choosing the content of the theological conversation? Or is that content being thrust upon them? There needs to be a recognition of both the beauty and the fallen-ness of culture whereby we are both purveyors and critics of it. If this is how we measure contextualization, then the voice of the house church must be heard, for their theology is a significant contributor to the conversation.

Share This Story

Further Reading

billow926-ND4-6joi3t8-unsplash
Qingdao: How to Pray
Read More
cajeo-zhang--Qkr9oCfcZo-unsplash
Qingdao: Locals and Outsiders
Read More
cajeo-zhang-CuoflMy9KIM-unsplash
Qingdao: Good Soil for the Gospel
Read More

LEADERSHIP DEVELOPMENT IN CHINA

With rising pressure and persecution in China, there are two challenges imperative for church leaders. The first challenge is for current leaders to love Christ above all else, and not to stray into legalism or love of the world. The second challenge is to raise up the next generation of leaders, who will humbly model Jesus even if current leaders are arrested.

WILL YOU JOIN US IN PRAYING FOR LEADERSHIP DEVELOPMENT IN CHINA? PRAY FOR:

  1. Current leaders to grow in their daily walks with Christ
  2. Current leaders to shepherd and raise up new leaders
  3. New leaders who love Christ and will model him to the world
  4. New leaders to love and care for the church

Videos

ABOUT LEADERSHIP DEVELOPMENT

About Shenyang

Shenyang is a city located in northeastern China and is the capital of Liaoning Province. It is known for its rich history and cultural heritage, including the Shenyang Imperial Palace, which is a UNESCO World Heritage site. Shenyang is also a hub for China’s heavy industry, with companies such as the China First Automobile Group and the Shenyang Aircraft Corporation having their headquarters in the city.

Videos

Stories from Shenyang

About Qingdao

Qingdao is a city located in eastern China and is famous for its beaches, beer, and seafood. The city is home to several landmarks, including the Zhanqiao Pier and the Badaguan Scenic Area. Qingdao is also a major port and has a thriving economy, with industries such as electronics, petrochemicals, and machinery.

Videos

Stories from Qingdao

About Xiamen

Xiamen is a city located in southeastern China and is a popular tourist destination known for its beautiful coastal scenery, including Gulangyu Island, which is a UNESCO World Heritage site. The city is also a hub for China’s high-tech industry, with companies such as Huawei and ZTE having research and development centers in Xiamen.

Videos

Stories from Xiamen

About Chongqing

Chongqing is a city located in southwestern China and is a major economic center in the region. The city is known for its spicy cuisine, especially its hot pot dishes, and is also famous for the Three Gorges Dam, the world’s largest hydroelectric dam. Chongqing is also home to several historic sites, including the Dazu Rock Carvings, which are UNESCO World Heritage sites.

Videos

Stories from Chongqing

About Nanjing

Nanjing is a city located in eastern China and is the capital of Jiangsu Province. It is one of China’s ancient capitals and has a rich cultural history, including the Ming Xiaoling Mausoleum, the Nanjing City Wall, and the Confucius Temple. Nanjing is also a modern city with a thriving economy and is home to several universities, including Nanjing University and Southeast University.

Videos

Stories from Nanjing

About Changchun

Changchun is a city located in northeastern China and is the capital of Jilin Province. It is known for its rich cultural heritage and is home to several historical landmarks such as the Puppet Emperor’s Palace and the Jingyuetan National Forest Park. Changchun is also a hub for China’s automotive industry, with several major automobile manufacturers having their headquarters in the city.

Videos

Stories from Changchun

About Guangzhou

Guangzhou, also known as Canton, is a city located in southern China and is the capital of Guangdong Province. It is one of the country’s largest and most prosperous cities, serving as a major transportation and trading hub for the region. Guangzhou is renowned for its modern architecture, including the Canton Tower and the Guangzhou Opera House, as well as its Cantonese cuisine, which is famous for its variety and bold flavors. The city also has a rich history, with landmarks such as the Chen Clan Ancestral Hall, the Sun Yat-sen Memorial Hall, and the Temple of the Six Banyan Trees. Additionally, Guangzhou hosts the annual Canton Fair, the largest trade fair in China.

Videos

Stories from Guangzhou

About Kunming

Kunming is a city located in southwest China and is the capital of Yunnan Province. Known as the “City of Eternal Spring” for its mild climate, Kunming is a popular tourist destination due to its natural beauty and cultural diversity. The city is home to several scenic spots, including the UNESCO World Heritage Site of the Stone Forest, Dian Lake, and the Western Hills. Kunming is also famous for its unique cuisine, which features a mix of Han, Yi, and Bai ethnic flavors. The city has a rich cultural history, with ancient temples and shrines like the Yuantong Temple and the Golden Temple, and it’s also a hub for Yunnan’s ethnic minority cultures, such as the Yi and Bai peoples.

Videos

Stories from Kunming

About Shenzhen

Shenzhen is a city located in southeastern China and is one of the country’s fastest-growing metropolises. The city is renowned for its thriving tech industry, with companies such as Huawei, Tencent, and DJI having their headquarters in Shenzhen. The city also has a vibrant cultural scene, with numerous museums, art galleries, and parks. Shenzhen is also known for its modern architecture, such as the Ping An Finance Center and the Shenzhen Bay Sports Center. Despite its modernization, Shenzhen also has a rich history and cultural heritage, with landmarks such as the Dapeng Fortress and the Chiwan Tin Hau Temple.

Videos

Stories from Shenzhen

About Chengdu

Chengdu is a city located in the southwestern region of China, and the capital of Sichuan province. It has a population of over 18 million people, and it is famous for its spicy Sichuan cuisine, laid-back lifestyle, and its cute and cuddly residents – the giant pandas. Chengdu is home to the Chengdu Research Base of Giant Panda Breeding, where visitors can observe these adorable creatures in their natural habitat. The city also boasts a rich cultural heritage, with numerous temples, museums, and historical sites scattered throughout its boundaries. Chengdu is a city of contrasts, with ancient traditions coexisting alongside modern developments, making it an intriguing and fascinating destination for visitors to China. 

Videos

Stories from Chengdu

About Beijing

Beijing is the capital city of China and one of the most populous cities in the world, with a population of over 21 million people. The city has a rich history that spans over 3,000 years, and it has served as the capital of various dynasties throughout China’s history. Beijing is home to some of the most iconic landmarks in China, including the Great Wall, the Forbidden City, and the Temple of Heaven. The city is also a hub for political, cultural, and educational activities, with numerous universities and research institutions located within its boundaries. Beijing is renowned for its traditional architecture, rich cuisine, and vibrant cultural scene, making it a must-visit destination for travelers to China.

Videos

Stories from Beijing

About Shanghai

Shanghai is a vibrant and dynamic city located on the eastern coast of China. It is the largest city in China and one of the most populous cities in the world, with a population of over 24 million people. Shanghai is a global financial hub and a major center for international trade, with a rich history and culture that spans over 1,000 years. The city is famous for its iconic skyline, which features towering skyscrapers such as the Oriental Pearl Tower and the Shanghai Tower. Shanghai is also home to a diverse culinary scene, world-class museums and art galleries, and numerous shopping districts. It is a city that is constantly evolving and reinventing itself, making it a fascinating destination for visitors from around the world.

Videos

Stories from Shanghai

give

A short message about partnering with us.